Charting a responsible path for discretionary spending. Budget concepts college of liberal arts oregon state university. Deep and dangerous cuts to international affairs budget. Nondefense discretionary ndd programs comprise domestic and international. Nondefense discretionary spending this year is the second highest since. The share of the budget going for discretionary spending has fallen from twothirds in 1962 to about onethird now. The united states federal budget consists of mandatory expenditures which includes medicare and social security, discretionary spending for defense, cabinet departments e. In this set of charts, we aim to frame the financial condition and fiscal outlook of the u. Heritage foundation book of charts retrieved march 18, 2010. Nondefense discretionary spending will soon fall below its historic low. This figure shows the effects of the recent budget changes, including the sequester, on nondefense discretionary spending.
The administration also erred in concentrating its steep spending cuts on nondefense discretionary programs a catchall that includes environmental. In nominal terms, total, defense, and nondefense discretionary outlays all roughly doubled from 1999 to 2018. Appropriations, 1997, ogc9823, january 19, 1998, available at. These programs are called discretionary because policymakers have the legal discretion to decide their funding levels each year through the appropriations process. Nondefense discretionary outlays the hamilton project. Government spending in the united states wikipedia.
View a printerfriendly pdf version requires adobe reader. The deficit reduction plan signed by president barack obama last week focused sharply on the narrow slice of the budget labeled as nondefense discretionary spending. In the united states, discretionary spending refers to optional spending set by appropriation levels each year, at the discretion of congress. In his 2019 budget, president trump once again proposes steady and massive cuts to nondefense appropriations nondefense discretionary funding or ndd, which fund a wide range of priorities such as education, job training, infrastructure, housing. Nondefense discretionary spending, which includes ovacs priority programs, accounts for less 20% of the federal budget see chart below.
All three of the plans would shrink all other spending largely made up of nondefense discretionary spending further. The various impacts are summarized in the cbo chart at right. Other than military salaries, every defense and nondefense account was reduced across the board, leading to the involuntary fur. In this set of charts, we aim to frame the financial condition and fiscal. A book of charts brian riedl senior fellow, manhattan institute september 2018. Military spending accounts for 55 percent of the presidents 2015 discretionary budget proposal, while nonmilitary spending accounts for 45 percent. End focus on numbers of ships, aircraft, or soldiers as a means of measuring military capability or force sufficiency.
What congress should do with the 2020 defense budget. Nondefense discretionary spending will soon be lower than it was in 2008. The budget process traditionally begins with the presidents budget. House budget committee staff february 19, 2019 page 3 discretionary spending has fallen over the. Indeed, as a percentage of gdp, federal ndd spending in 2018 is currently well below the 50year.
Beyond that, the administration calls for a further 2 percent per. The spending reduction elements of the fiscal cliff are primarily contained within the budget control act of 2011, which directed that both defense and nondefense discretionary spending be reduced by sequestration if congress was unable to agree on other spending cuts of similar size. Analysis of the presidents fy 2020 budget committee for. Current us discretionary federal budget and spending. Discretionary spending, both defense and domestic, makes up the balance, accounting for approximately onethird of federal spending. Us government discretionary spending is at a current level of 1. In the following discussion, we break ndd programs into seven categories, as the chart below shows. Nondefense discretionary spending nondefense discretionary spending ndd, also known as domestic discretionary spending, includes funding for domestic law enforcement, national parks, environmental protection, the judicial system and many other functions of government.
Soaring federal spending 3 discretionary spending is not driving the longterm debt 4 mandatory spending and entitlement costs are rising rapidly. Totaling about onethird of the federal budget, discretionary spending programs can be further divided into two categories. Expenditures in the united states federal budget wikipedia. In an attempt to avoid negotiating with congress about nondefense discretionary spending levels, the trump administration has submitted a request that technically complies with existing budget caps, but that increases defense spending considerably by more than tripling overseas contingency operations. However, the future years defense program fydp projection of the base defense budget. At the finest level of detail, you can click to read brief descriptions of what these. Mandatory spending, in contrast, occurs each year without such legislation.
Discretionary appropriations under the budget control act. I estimate that out of the total nondefense domestic discretionary spending in 2012, 44 percent was for competitiveness. Continuing resolutions, the budget control act, and. Nondefense definition of nondefense by merriamwebster. Trump budget would cut nondefense programs deeply in 2019. How paul ryan won the budget warin 1 chart the atlantic. The pgpf chart pack illustrates that budgetmaking involves many competing priorities, limited resources, and complex issues.
However, you may decide that you want to change the rules and provide your students with the freedom to disregard the caps and add chips to national defense andor nondefense discretionary spending categories. Trends in discretionary spending congressional research. Nondefense discretionary ndd programs comprise domestic and international programs outside of national defense that congress funds on an annual basis. Discretionary spending under the budget control act of 2011. Defense and other domestic spending is not projected to grow as a share of gdp. At its current trajectory, nondefense discretionary spending is on track to hit its lowest level in 50 years. Support the administrations plan to establish a space force, settling the question of how. The constitution gave congress the authority to raise and spend money for the federal government.
Todays spending levels are high by historical standards. Table 1 overview of changes to discretionary spending limits and the limits proposed in the. Nondefense discretionary spending ndd is only a small portion of the total budget, and it has fallen over time. Nondefense discretionary spending will soon fall below its historic low while categorizations of discretionary spending have varied in recent history, what we currently call nondefense. How has discretionary spending changed in recent years. Total discretionary spending increased by 121 percent. Essentially all spending on federal wages and salaries is 3 discretionary. The presidents nondefense budget moves in a completely opposite direction from legislation enacted on a bipartisan basis just last week. National defense spending is any government spending attributable to the maintenance and strengthening of the united states armed forces, including the army, navy, marines, and the air force. Discretionary spending is the part of federal spending that lawmakers control through annual appropriation acts. Defense and nondefense discretionary spending, fy1977fy2021.
To enact the largest sixyear nondefense discretionary spending hike, at the same time funding a war, has placed federal spending on an unsustainable path. Discretionary spending not including national defense is labeled non. Click on the slices of the federal budget pie to see where nondefense discretionary dollars actually go. Nondefense discretionary institute for spending reform. In todays increasingly competitive global economy, many. Nondefense definition is not related to or used for a nations military defenses.
However, while the justification book speaks mainly to the departments budgetary request in terms of discretionary budget authority, most tables in the green book display combined discretionary and mandatory funding. Congress must act now to raise the caps house budget. The budget includes topline agency totals for the defense and nondefense discretionary ndd budgets, but provides little detail related to specific program funding levels. The domestic discretionary category is very broad and diverse. Unlike mandatory spending, both the programs and the authorized levels of spending require regular renewal by congress. As of the fiscal year 2019 budget approved by congress, national defense is the largest discretionary expenditure in the federal budget. With respect to which agencies get how much money, this is the extent of the entire political process. Defense spending defense was the largest category of federal spending for several decades, first due to world war ii and then the military buildup in conjunction with the cold war. Discretionary spending discretionary spending covers programs that require appropriations by congress. Generally, it stays around 34% of gdp, hovering near 3. Our revised request is based on final fy 2017 appropriations, updated pay and nonpay.
National defense budget estimates for fy 2020 green book. This chart shows how funding for military and nonmilitary discretionary spending has changed over time. Discretionary and nondiscretionary federal spending in. For the past four fiscal years, discretionary spending levels the roughly onethird of federal spending controlled by congress on an annual basis have been set by twoyear budget agreements that have provided relief against spending reductions imposed. Trumps fiscal 2020 budget proposal released bloomberg. The scope of the law excludes major mandatory programs such as social security and medicare. The united states federal budget consists of mandatory expenditures discretionary spending. Figure d provides a historical picture of military spending over. Fy 2010 represented both a high water mark for discretionary spending and an anomaly, driven in part by a new majority, stimulus enacted through the appropriations process, and decennial census funding. Under these cuts this category of spending would fall to its lowest level in recent history. Discretionary spending is provided in, and controlled by, annual appropriations acts, which fund many of the routine activities commonly associated with such federal government functions as running executive branch agencies, congressional offices and agencies, and international 2 operations of the government.
944 342 1078 902 490 454 608 374 1100 347 807 625 1347 657 412 1316 790 550 808 914 1131 514 690 1093 432 234 34